Every review is built from structured data across up to ten categories, written by a named analyst and fact-checked before publication. Here is how the process works, and where its limits are.
Who runs this process
Reviews are written by Giles Thomas, edited by Rory Hughes and fact-checked by Tomislav Turčin.
The writer never signs off their own accuracy. 5 reviews are published under this methodology.
What we review
Each broker is scored out of 5 in up to ten categories, against documented criteria:
- Fees
- Safety & regulation
- Deposit & withdrawal
- Account opening
- Mobile app
- Web platform
- Assets
- Customer support
- Research & education
- South African suitability
How we collect and verify broker data
We use broker documents, fee schedules and pricing screens. Fees and account terms are checked against the broker’s own documents, with the date shown.
We open a real account as a South African resident for every review, and fund, trade and withdraw where the review says so. Where we have not, as with AvaTrade so far, the review says which steps are still to be tested. Spreads, trading costs and withdrawal times we measure on a funded account carry the date they were captured.
Every FSCA licence is checked on the FSCA's register, and any overseas licence we have not yet checked on its regulator's register is marked as such. We find the entity that would contract with a South African client and name the regulator that licenses it: the FSCA for a South African company, the home regulator for one abroad. The South African authorities, and what each covers:
- FSCA: Financial Sector Conduct Authority. Market-conduct regulator. Licenses financial services providers, including forex and CFD brokers, and keeps the public register of them.
- Prudential Authority: Prudential Authority within the South African Reserve Bank. Supervises banks, insurers and market infrastructure, rather than licensing brokers.
- FIC: Financial Intelligence Centre. South Africa's financial intelligence unit: the anti-money-laundering reporting behind the FICA checks banks, brokers and other accountable institutions carry out.
Which entity we tested
If one entity arranges your account while another holds your money, we say so, and we name the entity our test account was opened with.
How we score brokers
The overall score is calculated from the category scores, not set by hand. One methodology applies to every broker in the same way, and non-partner brokers can outrank partners.
The overall score is a weighted mean: safety and regulation carries 23%, and the other categories share the remaining 77% equally. An untested category is left out, not scored zero.
In safety and regulation, an FSCA approval as an over-the-counter derivative provider (ODP) for the company that holds your account counts in a broker's favour. Its absence is not a finding that the broker has broken any rule: where that company is abroad, the review names the regulator that supervises it.
It is calculated, never typed in, so it cannot contradict the sub-scores beside it, and there is no field in which a headline number could be adjusted for a partner. No broker pays for placement or ranking order.
South African suitability feeds the overall like any other category, and is also shown on its own in each review.
- 1 Score each category out of 5
From the regulator’s register, the broker’s own documents and a funded account.
- 2 Weight safety at 23%
The other tested categories share the remaining 77% equally.
- 3 Add up and round
To one decimal place. That is the overall score, and nobody types it in.
Where the weight goes when all 10 categories are tested
- Safety & regulation 23%
- Fees 8.6%
- Deposit & withdrawal 8.6%
- Account opening 8.6%
- Mobile app 8.6%
- Web platform 8.6%
- Assets 8.6%
- Customer support 8.6%
- Research & education 8.6%
- South African suitability 8.6%
Overall = Safety × 23% + Average of the other tested categories × 77%
Worked example
An illustrative broker, not a real rating: strong platforms and funding, a weak licence, and one category not yet tested.
- Safety & regulation
- 2.0 × 23% = 0.460
- Average of the other 8 tested
- 4.5 × 77% = 3.465
- Overall score
- 3.925, rounded to 3.9
- A plain average of the 9 scores would be 4.2. Weighting safety at 23% holds a weakly licensed broker to 3.9, however good its platforms are.
- Leaving the untested category out shares the 77% 8 ways, 9.6% each. Scoring it zero would give 3.5, a penalty for something we never measured.
What we have not measured yet
A measurement we have not taken is published as pending, never estimated, and the table says so. A broker’s indicative spread is not a measurement: we would rather show a gap than disguise one.
AvaTrade is still to be tested on Fees, Deposit & withdrawal, Mobile app, Customer support, Research & education and South African suitability. JustMarkets is still to be tested on Web platform.
Until the following are measured on every ranked broker, the matching sections stay gated:
- Spreads and all-in trading cost.
- Execution quality and slippage.
- Deposit and withdrawal times, including the ZAR conversion applied.
How often we update data
Reviews are revisited on a recurring cycle, and at once when a broker’s regulatory status changes. Each figure carries the date it was checked.
How we handle affiliate partners
Affiliate status has no bearing on scores; how we earn money is set out on our how we make money page.
Limitations of our reviews
Terms vary by entity and residency, and our reviews are not personal advice. Check the details with the broker and the regulator before you deposit.
Ready to compare brokers?
Compare the brokers available in South Africa by fees, regulation, platforms and account features.
Frequently asked questions
How are overall scores calculated?
Do you test brokers with real money?
Does affiliate status affect a broker’s score?
Which regulators do you check?
ForexBroker SA is an informational broker comparison site. We do not provide personalised investment advice. Trading and investing involve risk, and you may lose some or all of your capital.